Yahoo! News News Home - Yahoo! - Help

AP
Welcome, Guest Personalize News Home Page   -   Sign In
Yahoo! News   Sun, Jun 29, 2003
Search    for     Advanced
News Front Page
Top Stories
Business
World
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Politics
   White House
   Elections
   Congress
   U.S. Government
   World
   Supreme Court
   Press Releases
Most Popular
Science
Health
Oddly Enough
Op/Ed
Lifestyle
Local
Comics
News Photos
Most Popular
Weather
Audio/Video
Full Coverage
Lottery
Crosswords
News for Kids

Full Coverage
More about
Supreme Court
Related News Stories
Supreme Court Will Settle Privacy Case AP (Jun 27, 2003)
U.S. Supreme Court lifts ban on sodomy Globe and Mail. (Jun 27, 2003)
Justices, 6-3, Legalize Gay Sexual Conduct in Sweeping Reversal NY Times (registration req'd) (Jun 27, 2003)
Opinion & Editorials
Truth From Justice Ginsburg Washington Post (Jun 28, 2003)
Mr. Diversity NY Times (registration req'd) (Jun 28, 2003)
Court Vacancy Needn't Lead to Political Bloodletting Newsday (Jun 27, 2003)
Feature Articles
Supreme Court Looking Less Conservative AP (Jun 28, 2003)
Supreme Court's Rulings on Gays, Race Surprises Reuters (Jun 27, 2003)
Related Web Sites
Supreme Court of the United States
U.S. Supreme Court Guide
FindLaw Supreme Court Center

News Resources
Providers
· AP
News Alerts
· Antonin Scalia
· Clarence Thomas
· Sandra Day O'Connor
· President Bush
Search News

Search:

for

Advanced

Politics Tools
· Register to Vote
Enter Your ZIP Code to
Find a Candidate:

or Search by State
· Issues & Action
Scroll to select issue area
· Elected Officials
Enter Your ZIP Code:

or Search by State
· Contact The Media
Enter Your ZIP Code:

or Search by State

Links and services provided by Capitol Advantage
 
Supreme Court - AP
Supreme Court Looking Less Conservative
Sat Jun 28, 8:37 PM ET

By ANNE GEARAN, Associated Press Writer

WASHINGTON - In blockbuster rulings on affirmative action and gay rights and in less heralded decisions this term, a Supreme Court dominated by conservative jurists looked less conservative than it has in years.

Photo
AP Photo

 

"On vitally important issues to social conservatives, they suffered serious defeats this term," said Thomas Goldstein, a Washington lawyer who specializes in the Supreme Court. "There was not a single victory to balance it out."

Serendipity plays a role in the mix of cases the court hears in a given year, and it can be misleading to look at any one year in isolation.

Still, the 2002-2003 session will be remembered for its exceptions to the conservative rule, lawyers and law professors said.

In the term that ended last week, the high court bolted from a decade of rulings striking down or limiting racial formulas, and upheld the continued use of race as a factor in university admissions.

The justices also made an about-face on the question of whether gay men and women can be prosecuted for what they do in the privacy of their bedrooms. That caused one of the court's core conservatives, Justice Antonin Scalia (news - web sites), to sputter that his colleagues had "taken sides in the culture war."

No less a conservative stalwart than Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist led the majority this spring in departing from the court's march to increase state rights at the expense of federal control in a case about family leave for state workers.

The court also upheld a legal aid financing program for the poor that political conservatives called an unconstitutional government assault on private property.

"These decisions were not as conservative as might have been expected," said Emory University law professor Robert Schapiro. "The affirmative action ruling is one I'll be teaching for many years to come."

The court's work left Douglas Kmiec, a Pepperdine University constitutional law professor and former legal adviser to Republican presidents, shaking his head.

"In affirmative action, federal-state relations, and, after the sodomy case, basic — and I do mean very basic — principles of constitutional interpretation have been tossed aside, not conserved."

That is not to say the court abandoned its conservative leanings.

A string of law-and-order rulings strengthened government powers to go after suspects and punish criminals. For example, the court upheld the nation's strictest "three-strikes" law, ruling that a California man's 50-years-to-life sentence for stealing videotapes was not unconstitutionally harsh.

Those tough-on-crime rulings were in keeping with the court's rightward shift under Rehnquist's leadership, a path that has taken the court far from its progressive stance under the Civil Rights era stewardship of Chief Justice Earl Warren.

It is a mark of the current court's fundamentally conservative outlook that all nine justices voted to allow Michigan to cancel family visits for prisoners caught with drugs, and that a six-member majority said Congress can require public libraries to block objectionable material on their Internet terminals or lose federal money.

Rehnquist and fellow conservative Justices Scalia and Clarence Thomas (news - web sites) still held sway in a large percentage of the 73 cases decided this term. The three usually vote together and prevail when they can attract one or both of the court's center-right justices, Reagan appointees Sandra Day O'Connor (news - web sites) and Anthony M. Kennedy.

It was O'Connor who joined more liberal justices to preserve affirmative action. That vote was 5-4. It was Kennedy who provided the crucial vote in the sodomy case.

 

In that case, the court set out a constitutionally protected right to adults' private sexual conduct. The government has no business peeping in bedroom windows, the court said in a ruling written by Kennedy.

O'Connor also voted to strike down a Texas sodomy ban, making the overall ruling 6-3, but she would not go nearly as far as Kennedy and her more liberal colleagues.

Religious broadcaster Pat Robertson was among many conservatives who condemned the decision, which he said would take the nation "down into a moral sewer."

The nine justices closed their term without any announcement of an impending retirement.

An opening on the court had been hotly anticipated on Capitol Hill and elsewhere, since it would give President Bush (news - web sites) his first opportunity to name a Supreme Court justice.

The anticipation peaked with release of the court's final opinions Thursday, the day the court most disappointed political and social conservatives with its gay rights ruling.

"No justice may have retired physically, but a number managed to retire intellectually," Kmiec said.


Mail to Friend  Email Story
Message Boards   Post/Read Msgs (598)
Printer Version   Print Story
Ratings: Would you recommend this story?
Not at all 1 - 2 - 3 - 4 - 5 Highly



Prev. Story: 'Do Not-Call' List Is Hit With Consumers  (AP)
Next Story: Rice Heads to Mideast for Gaza Talks  (AP)

More Supreme Court Stories
· Rehnquist Speaks at Judicial Conference   (AP)
· Supreme Court by the Numbers   (AP)
· Major Rulings in This Supreme Court Term   (AP)
· High Court Weighs Congressional Districts   (AP)
· Group Wants Judge Punished for Race Case   (AP)


Save $50-$150 Instantly on all TVs 30" and up
Weekly Specials ADVERTISEMENT
· NOW Find Anyones Email-ALL FREE-Worlds Largest Directory ADDRESSES.COM
· Save up to 30% on Accessories at Nokia.com/us
· Car Payment too High Because of Your Credit? Refinance Today!
· Refinance NOW and GET CASH! FREE Quote!
· Check out Toyota's quality cars, trucks and SUVs at toyota.com..
· Shop & Compare for Term Life Insurance with ReliaQuote
· Chase® Platinum Visa: 0% Intro APR, No Annual Fee. Click to Apply!
· Tiny, Wireless Video Camera Kit ONLY $79.99!
· Save money now...GEICO.com
Platinum

ADVERTISEMENT

Services
Daily Emails
Free News Alerts

Copyright © 2003 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. The information contained in the AP News report may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without the prior written authority of The Associated Press.
Copyright © 2003 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Questions or Comments
Privacy Policy -Terms of Service - Copyright Policy - Ad Feedback