Israel's daily newsmagazine
   Israel's daily newsmagazine
June 24, 2003
| home |   security |   politics |   diplomacy |   culture |   travel |   views | shopping |   community
 


06/24  Rabbis: No government has the right to set up a foreign state in the land of Israel
Haaretz

06/24  Rabbis: Road map is against the Torah
Jerusalem Post










 

Sign up for free!

E-mail
 
    daily: free trial    
    weekly: free    
       
    more info    

Call Israel Now!
4.5 cents to Israel and state to state! Sign up now!
Whistleblower Magazine
Check out Joseph Farah's controversial monthly publication.
A Psalm in Jenin
The Insider story of the Israeli soldiers in Jenin.
News from Israel
Special offer! Six months of daily news and views for $28.
Virtual Kibbutz
Short story collection raises question of kibbutz's future.
Learn Hebrew!
Use a Hebrew speaking handheld electronic dictionary.
Order Peace Fire!
A kaleidoscope of perspectives on the Arab-Israeli conflict.
Insider Personals
Find your perfect match in our singles dating directory.






Rabbis say Torah forbids road map compliance
By Ellis Shuman  June 24, 2003


"The road map is worse than Oslo," declared former Knesset member Rabbi Haim Druckman.
Security officials fear extremists may violently protest outpost dismantling
West Bank rabbis urge soldiers to refuse orders to dismantle illegal outposts
Leading West Bank rabbi says IDF commanders could execute "refuseniks"

 
 
"The agreement called 'the road map' is in complete contradiction to the wisdom of the Torah," declared a conference called by the Rabbis' Union for the People and Land of Israel in Jerusalem on Monday. The emergency meeting of the group, which was established ten years ago in response to the Oslo Accords, said no Israeli government has the authority to give away a portion of Israel for the establishment of a Palestinian state.

Some 500 Orthodox rabbis, described by the Jerusalem Post as both right-wing and centrist, attended the conference in order to form a joint response to the "road map" peace initiative and the government's decision to dismantle unauthorized outposts in the West Bank. Declarations issued at the conference said, "No government has the authority to declare the establishment of an alien state or to abandon parts of the Land of Israel to aliens," and "The government is prohibited by a clear and absolute Torah prohibition from evacuating an outpost or a settlement."

"We speak on behalf of the Jewish people -- past, present and future. It is forbidden to give the land away," Rabbi Shalom Gold of Jerusalem's Har Nof congregation said.

Well-known rabbinical leaders attending the conference included former chief rabbis Mordechai Eliahu and Avraham Shapira, and former Knesset member Haim Druckman. Shapira declared that handing over territories is a "particularly grave transgression."

"No one in the world, from drawers of water and hewers of stone to prime ministers, has the right to give up one grain of the Land of Israel," Eliahu declared.

Druckman said that the "road map" resurrected the mistakes of the Oslo Accords. "Have we been dazzled? Have we been taken over by blindness? The road map is worse than Oslo, and now after more than 1,000 dead and thousands of wounded and disabled, the eyes of the government have ceased to see," Druckman said.

Beit El Yeshiva head Rabbi Zalman Melamed defended the actions of settlers who had refused to evacuate the Mitzpe Yitzhar outpost last week. They displayed "martyrdom for the sake of the Holy Name. For every outpost that is evacuated, five new ones will arise," Melamed said.

"The terrible act of evacuating outposts is liable to lead to an all-out plan of uprooting settlements," the Rabbis' Union said in a resolution. "The government is under a biblical prohibition against evacuating any outpost or settlement."

The rabbis warned, however, of violent resistance against Israeli soldiers under orders to dismantle outposts. "All forms of violence, whether physical or oral, should be avoided against our dear brothers - the soldiers - and against our dear brothers - the settlers," the rabbis declared in a statement.

 
 Talk Back! Respond to this article


 
 
roadmap to distruction
Guest  - Zutphen, Netherlands  (06/24/2003 09:50 IT) 
Hi
Yossi_Ha_Matoc  - Israel  (06/24/2003 13:19 IT) 
More jewish racism
Ahmed_Negm  - Alexandria, Egypt  (06/24/2003 16:18 IT) 
Re: More jewish racism
DavidF  - Silver Spring, U.S.A  (06/24/2003 17:39 IT) 
Re: Re: More jewish racism/David
gaylelee  - U.S.A  (06/24/2003 19:24 IT) 
Is religious intransigence the best bet for peace?
Jamzie193  - London, United Kingdom  (06/24/2003 21:38 IT) 
AHMED - MORE ARROGANT IGNORANCE
Send email to writer GIDEON  - U.S.A  (06/24/2003 21:48 IT) 
*AHMED* SHOULD JEWS GET MEDINA BACK??!
Send email to writer GIDEON  - U.S.A  (06/24/2003 22:10 IT) 
*AHMED* A MUSLIM "BILL OF RIGHTS"
Send email to writer GIDEON  - U.S.A  (06/24/2003 22:16 IT) 
Re: *AHMED* A MUSLIM
Satyagraha  - Cambridge, U.S.A  (06/24/2003 23:01 IT) 
Re: Re: *AHMED* A MUSLIM
Jamzie193  - London, United Kingdom  (06/24/2003 23:26 IT) 
"Giedon" a jewish
Ahmed_Negm  - Alexandria, Egypt  (06/24/2003 23:37 IT) 
to Satyagraha
nicky0104  - U.S.A  (06/24/2003 23:40 IT) 
Re: to Satyagraha
Jamzie193  - London, United Kingdom  (06/24/2003 23:59 IT) 
AHMED - YOU *ALMOST* GET IT...BUT
Send email to writer GIDEON  - U.S.A  (06/25/2003 00:05 IT) 
**SATYA** STILL DILLUTING YOURSELF?!?!?
Send email to writer GIDEON  - U.S.A  (06/25/2003 00:18 IT) 
Re: Re: to Satyagraha
wharold  - Calgary, Canada  (06/25/2003 00:23 IT) 
*SATYA* EVER READ UN-RES #242 OR 338?!?!
Send email to writer GIDEON  - U.S.A  (06/25/2003 00:28 IT) 
Ct: *SATYA* EVER READ UN-RES #242 OR 338?!?!
Send email to writer GIDEON  - U.S.A  (06/25/2003 00:29 IT) 
**AHMED** ARAB DEPUTY MAYOR OF TEL-AVIV
Send email to writer GIDEON  - U.S.A  (06/25/2003 00:41 IT) 

Click on the blue headline to read a Talkback comment and respond to it. Click on the icon to send a private email to the talkback writer. The icon appears only if the writer has decided to be contacted.
 
  | about |   partners |   sponsor |   donate |   news |   subscribe |   contact |