FT.com
 
. All times are London time.
 

Home UK 
Asia | Europe | US 
World
Business
Markets
Markets data & tools
Industries
Lex
Comment & analysis
Your money
Arts & Weekend
Sport
Jobs & education
In today's FT
Site services
FT Reports
Creative Business
FTfm
FT-IT
World reports
Special reports


Columnists
   Martin Wolf
 Lucy Kellaway
 Quentin Peel
 Amity Shlaes
 Gerard Baker

Discussions
   Iraq's WMD: Was war justified?
 EU referendum
 UK house prices
 China's economic growth

Partner sites
   Business.com
 Hoover's Online
 Chinese.FT.com
 Les Echos
 FT Deutschland
 Recoletos
 Vedomosti
 CBS MarketWatch
 Investors Chronicle

Home UK  Print article | Email
Doubts mount on Powell's evidence to UN
By Hubert Wetzel in Washington
Published: July 29 2003 20:28 | Last Updated: July 29 2003 20:28

Colin Powell, US secretary of state, was advised that the evidence he cited in his speech to the United Nations in February concerning Iraq's nuclear weapons programme was questionable.

The bureau of Intelligence and Research (INR), the State Department's in-house analysis unit, and nuclear experts at the Department of Energy are understood to have explicitly warned Mr Powell during the preparation of his speech that the evidence was questionable.

In the presentation, in which the US laid out its case for a pre-emptive war on Iraq, Mr Powell accused Iraq of importing special aluminium tubes as evidence that Baghdad was still working on a programme to produce atomic weapons.

But the INR disputed claims by the CIA and the Pentagon that the tubes were intended for a nuclear weapons programme. While the INR and the Energy Department had already made their opposition known in a footnote to the top-secret National Intelligence Estimate prepared in October 2002, the bureau is understood to have again told Mr Powell during the preparation of his February speech that its analysts were not persuaded that the tubes could be used in centrifuges to enrich uranium.

In the controversy over pre-war intelligence on Iraq, both the White House and the Central Intelligence Agency have taken blame for questionable claims made by President George W. Bush.

But Colin Powell, the US secretary of state, has escaped such scrutiny despite having delivered a critical February 5 presentation to the United Nations that ignored strong doubts within the US government about the truth of one of the central elements of its claim that Iraq was reconstituting a nuclear weapons programme.

While most of the attention has focused on Mr Bush's now-discredited claim that Iraq was attempting to buy uranium from Africa, Mr Powell's claims about the tubes have not held up much better under scrutiny.

Iraq, he alleged, had attempted to buy the tubes from 11 countries - efforts that continued last year even after weapons inspectors arrived in Baghdad. Mr Powell acknowledged there were "differences of opinion" among experts in the US government on their intended use but some insisted they were of a quality far higher than the US used in artillery rockets, the use the Iraqi government had claimed for them.

Inspectors of the International Atomic Energy Agency said in March, however, that it was "highly unlikely that Iraq could have achieved the considerable redesign to use them in a revived centrifuge programme", the use for which Mr Powell argued they were intended.

email this EMAIL THIS print this PRINT THIS most popular MOST POPULAR  
Related stories
Looting thwarts efforts to bring back power  Jul 31 2003 18:54
US struggles to cobble together troop force  Jul 31 2003 18:10
Lex: Currencies  Jul 31 2003 13:11 Requires subscription
Bush urges EU to pursue Iran over N-weapons  Jul 30 2003 20:54
How to slide into a third Gulf war  Jul 30 2003 20:23
Consumer confidence suffers surprise fall  Jul 30 2003 00:35
Nato forces struggle to return Bosnia to self-rule  Jul 29 2003 18:29 Requires subscription
Fans tire of bad behaviour  Jul 29 2003 05:00
US presses India to supply Iraq peacekeepers  Jul 28 2003 22:33
Poor results at paper producers  Jul 28 2003 10:24 Requires subscription
Requires subscription = requires subscription to FT.com
Search & quotes

NewsQuotes
  • Power searchRequires subscription
  • My portfolio

  • Editor's choice
      Europe and America put off their divorce Requires subscription

    Howard approval ratings survive Iraq controversy Requires subscription

    White House releases top secret WMD papers Requires subscription

    Email & tools
       News by email
     Personal office
     Download news ticker
     Currency converter

    Research tools
       Analyst reports
     FT Research Centre
     Free annual reports
     Market research
     Growth companies
     D&B business reports

      Home World | Business | Markets news | Markets data & tools | Industries | Lex | Your money | Comment & analysis | Reports | Arts & Weekend | Sport | Jobs & education | In today's FT | Media inquiries Contact us | Help